Profit through generosity

Friday, March 26, 2010 by Administrator

The number one question I always get asked is how Umbraco is making money and how on earth we can be profitable when we give things away for free. Our business philosophy is internally coined as "Profit through generosity". Not only do we believe that generosity - not to confuse with philanthropy -  leads to business, but we've also walked the walk and proven for almost two years that it's sustainable.

Let's start with some tiny facts about Umbraco HQ (the company):

  • We have been profitable since Q2 2008
  • We're four employees
  • We see ourselves as an equal part and participant of the Umbraco community
  • We make our money by adding value to the Umbraco CMS ecosystem
  • We use the profit to work on the core of Umbraco CMS

And here's some on the Umbraco CMS:

Our sources of revenue are three:

Our mighty training/certification empire
We've developed a very successful and appreciated course system. In the beginning all courses were run be ourselves but now we've started to franchise the system to other key persons in the Umbraco CMS community.

Why this adds value: We ensure that people learn to use Umbraco CMS in the very best way, we take responsibility in terms of setting a standard for what makes a skilled Umbraco Developer/Solution Provider which makes it easier for companies to screen the market. For Umbraco HQ it gives a stable and predictable income which in returns gets invested in the core product.

Umbraco.tv
While the above is awesome for the people attending, it's not for all. Not only do the courses (almost) always sell out, but the price tag and regional availability can prevent it from a broader appeal. This is why we introduced umbraco.tv in the fall of 2008. It doesn't replace the courses, but enable us to share our knowledge with many people at a very low price while still ensuring a revenue flow.

Why this adds value: It makes it easy for everyone to get started with Umbraco CMS at a price less than a book. Being a service it also lets us add more and more content to people who subscribe ensuring that they can keep improving their skill sets also on very narrow topics which makes it an awesome supplement to the courses. For Umbraco HQ it's a source of income that both scales and is attractive for the huge and constantly growing user base. For me - this is likely the product that I'm most proud of.

Umbraco PRO
This was for a lack of a better name and I hope it'll change in the future. Umbraco PRO is our supported and guaranteed version of Umbraco CMS. Today it's a mashup of different services and products we had in the beginning, but we're starting to release the product in the bundle as individual offerings with our successful form designer - Umbraco Contour - being the first. At the very heart of it, Umbraco PRO tries to solve some of the concerns we meet from bigger companies. With Umbraco PRO they get better bug fixing warranty than any standard Web CMS EULA meets and with the support option on top, they get stellar tech support from the very people who make the software.

Why this adds value: The bug fixing warranty brings great comfort for companies and the support not only ensures that companies and solution providers can get solid answers in very short time but also ensures that we - the company - get a great sense of what areas of Umbraco CMS need more attention.

As our revenue sources clearly show, our business is not rocket science. We use the power of our brand, trademarks and knowledge to ensure revenue. The more people using Umbraco CMS, the bigger market for our services. Hence a strong motivation for a solid core product. Hence a motivation to invest back directly on the product [generosity] as it makes the platform more attractive.

And while some might argue that our business is small, Umbraco is fast-forwarding towards one of the biggest install bases for Microsoft based Web CMS. This while being strongly profitable. Something very few VC-backed projects can boast. You don't need to be big to make change. But you need to be profitable to be sustainable long term.

Our business model is a perfect mashup of ongoing trends such as Freemium, Transparency and Open Source and at the same time we get to do what we love - being part of a stunning change backed by the most wonderful community.

That's sustainable change.

9 comment(s) for “Profit through generosity”

  1. Gravatar ImageAlex Norcliffe Says:

    As the guy who brought Umbraco into Condé Nast for Wired and setting us up for the rest that followed (Vogue Japan, Vogue Italy, Style.it, GQ UK, CNTraveller.com, etc.) I have to say I looked at Umbraco HQ's model very closely when it came to making the decision vs other, more traditionally "enterprise" off-the-shelf products. And ultimately it is something which works very well. After this post, even their model is open-source ;)

    Having a CMS product which has a wide base of experienced producers and developers means that when you're in the position to choose Umbraco CMS as a solution, you not only have zero up-front license costs but you have lower production and maintenance costs. Other enterprise level products not only have huge fees to get into the playground, but once you're there there are fewer players so competition is more fierce and you pay twice the day-rate just to get your site built. Do you know a cheap but expert TeamSite developer?

    The flexibility of a product that can install quickly as a blog in minutes, but be lightweight enough that it can scale to larger concerns, combined with having access to experienced implementors at a much cheaper rate than normal, cannot be underestimated.

    Umbraco HQ's model to embrace this and help to spread the producer/developer pool through paid training is a key strategy enabling this.

  2. Gravatar ImageMichael Tott Says:

    I could not agree more.

    For me being able to start with the free and without the risk has made me a customer.

    The Umbraco.tv is great and I often dive in to get a quick answer.

    Just need to get on the training now.

  3. Gravatar ImageMichael Sieber Says:

    As the one in charge of technology for the Aspria Group in Europe, I completly agree with Alex.

    We have started the switch to umbraco more than three years ago and have just completed the rollout of the new websites based on umbraco 4 in 4 languages and 3 countries.

    And knowing the community for quite a while, I think the community really apreciates the umbraco way of doing business.

  4. Gravatar ImageBen Aggus Says:

    This really makes me feel better about using Umbraco without being Pro.

    The simple fact is that I have $0 budget to work with. I work for a city that has had to lay off police officers due to budget cuts. It's hard to justify a $10k CMS in times like these.

    I kind of felt bad, in that I wasn't giving back $$$ for such a great product. I have an Umbraco.tv membership, but I pay for it out of my own pocket.

    If I had a budget or worked for a private company, I would go Pro in an instant, but it's nice to know I can use the product until then.

  5. Gravatar Imageanony Says:

    Let's hope the latest support on Umbraco Pro is stronger than the original offering. Long turn around on tickets and a general lack of responsiveness led the powers to be at my former company to move to a more robustly supported platform after initially building out on umbraco. Additionally, while external development costs may be low due to the small shops providing the service, many did not meet our vendor/contractor requirements (diversity, insurance, etc.) leaving us to rely on internal developer resources....nice if you've got them but even large companies have cut many of those positions or keep them over subscribed.

  6. Gravatar ImageRyan Maas Says:

    I looked around, and around, and around for a solid .NET CMS offering and kept coming back to U. For me the budget was small but the need for ultimate control was very high, as is usually the case. After showing what I call the "growth path", starting with templates, then XSLT Macros, then ASCX Macros, the class libraries and on to Python, my team saw the light and agreed this is the best product out there for our situation. We needed .Net/MS all the way through. It's been great getting a handle on the ins and outs of the framework. Sure, there are a few small quirks here and there. Name me one system that doesn't have that! All in all, really a solid product.

    Next up training and certification in Austin, TX. Can't wait!

  7. Gravatar ImageFreebie Says:

    it's rather weird to read the ceo's post on how he does business and why he does it. Most of us don't give a damn about that for sure

    what really matters is how much 4 families need to survive. where I live, that would be around 40.000 $ each month. are you making 40.000 $ each month just by providing umbraco? i hope you do, but i'm sure you don't.

    you can sure have a philosophy about generosity but in the end only the money you make really counts these days

    there might have been 80.000 installations, but how many of these made it to successful websites? in my experience, that would only be at around 5%. and since most of these webmasters just look into a free solution, are they willing to pay anything? that is the case for only another 5% i guess. so in total you probably only have 200 paying customers.

    well, this is just a random reply to a random blog post, i agree, but why don't you just post your monthly turnover in this blog? it would make more sense i think

  8. Gravatar ImageHartvig Says:

    @Freebie:
    What I felt important to emphasize in my blog post, was that we have four brilliant *fulltime* employees on staff and that's what's needed currently to support the massive momentum that Umbraco experience. All while still being able to make a profit to ensure further growth for the platform AND all while still staying true to the community.

  9. Gravatar ImageSoeren Sprogoe Says:

    I love the "...at a price less than a book".

    You should make that a catch phrase for Umbraco.tv :-)

Leave a comment